JT Hodges and his wife Kasey welcomed a baby girl!

Delta Fay Hodges arrived on Friday, Oct. 12 in Nashville, weighing in at 9 lbs., 4 oz.

“She had my heart from first sight — I’m just so proud,” the proud dad tells PEOPLE. “I’m also damn thankful she looks like her mama!”

This is the second baby for the couple as baby Delta joins big sis Charlee Joy, 22 months.